A unique collaboration brought energy modeling and efficiency measures into the renovation of the former National Guard Armory in Rochester—now dubbed the Castle Community. The measures are expected to reduce energy use by 20% when the building reopens as a multi-use space consisting of a restaurant, artist studios, gallery, and community gathering and events center.
Building a Team
General contractor Benike Construction wanted to promote efficiency in the Castle Community redevelopment. They approached the project owner, Scott Hoss, and then enlisted the help of Dru Larson from Rochester Public Utilities (RPU), and Kevin Bright, Energy and Sustainability Director at Destination Medical Center (DMC). Together the team applied for a CERTs Seed Grant. The grant was to fund a whole-building modeling approach that looked at the envelope and mechanical systems with a goal to implement any efficiency measures that could provide a simple payback of 3 years or less. RPU supported the project as exploration of a potential future energy efficiency retrofit incentive program, and DMC to educate and spur change in private redevelopments.
The Castle Community project was definitely worth the effort. For developers like us, having numbers to back up the potential savings from energy efficiency choices is critical.
Mike Benike, Benike Construction
Exploring Efficiency Opportunities
The awarded CERTs Seed Grant funding was only $1,000—not nearly enough for the proposed energy modeling—but the team had the expertise to work with what they had. Ultimately, Minnesota Energy Resources, the natural gas supplier, was able to provide baseline energy use estimates and recommendations through their Design Assistance and Modeling Program. The Armory wasn’t a perfect fit for the available tools since not all of the mechanicals were being replaced and the building had some complexities—the existing system had been modified over the last four decades. The modeling revealed that lighting, a direct digital control system, and upgrades to variable frequency drives for pumps and motors had the greatest potential savings.
Mike Benike and Dru Larson check out the electrical panel in the Cameo Restaurant kitchen
As a result, LED lighting with an advanced control system was used and various components of the HVAC systems were upgraded or rebuilt when cost effective, including zone controls installed in the hydronic heating system. Prior to these zone valve controls, the hot water heating system “ran wild” all throughout the heating season. The kitchen for the Cameo restaurant was fitted with an on-demand variable-speed exhaust hood and a ventless dishwasher was installed that condenses water vapor for the final rinse, saving both energy and water.
Kevin Bright and Mike Benike examining rebuilt boilers for the hydronic heating system
Reflecting on the Project
Over refreshments in the Cameo Restaurant in Castle Community after a tour of the building, Mike Benike shared that for small developers, “having numbers to back up the potential savings from energy efficiency choices is critical.” For Mike, the Castle Community project was “definitely worth the effort.” DMC’s Kevin Bright said the project was successful because lessons learned would “provide future guidance on community projects and programs.” Dru Larson indicated that RPU had already used the information to support use of more robust tools in subsequent pilot projects they are working on.
Technology: Low-cost / no-cost upgrades, lighting upgrades, heating or cooling equipment, energy modeling
Southeast CERT Seed Grant: $1,500
Total Project Cost: $2,500,000
Other Funds: gas and electric utilities, project owner, in-kind from contractor and construction companies
Project Team: John Honeck, Jon Klug, Brett Colsch (Harris Companies), Dru Larson (Rochester Public Utilities), Kevin Bright (Destination Medical Center / City of Rochester), Scott Hoss (Owner of Castle Community), Michael Resech (Residential Science Resources)
People Involved and Reached: 707
Annual Energy Savings: 35,000 kWh
Could a CERTs Seed Grant help your community project shine?